Big Brother, George Orwell, Nineteen eighty-four, 1984, War is Peace, Ignorance is Strength, Freedom is Slavery, Watching You, Net Neutrality, Censorship, FCC, Ajit Pai, Donald Trump

Net Neutrality is a Free Speech Issue

The Brood: The FCC is considering changing the rules regulating the internet, giving telecommunications companies the power to reward or punish companies that compete with them, and silence any views contrary to their interests. It’s only one other way that Free Speech is being threatened by the digital age.

Imagine you are a media critic. You want to go on a Jon Stewart level rant about how broken the journalism of the 21st century is. Or perhaps you are a journalist yourself, and a public policy driven one like the crew over at Vox. Particularly you want to target MSNBC. You get your cable, internet and phone service from Comcast, which owns MSNBC.

Jon Stewart, Crossfire, Media, Critique, CNN, Liberal, Conservative, Media, Fake News, Journalism, Pat Buchanan, Thomas Braden, Tucker Carlson, Paul Begala
Jon Stewart literally gets a television show canceled in 2004. Still one of the best moments of media critique in history. [Image Source]
If Comcast gets the changes it wants through the FCC, it will see widely shared critiques of their many assets, in this case MSNBC, as competition, or at the very least bad for business. To make that material less available, they decide that they will slow down internet speeds specifically for that website. Or they will simply charge consumers more for faster internet speeds in bundles, favoring friendly media platforms over others.

This, in brief, is the issue of Net Neutrality. (If you want a more full, and entertaining, explanation, you can see not one, not two, but three pieces of John Oliver’s work on this.) Net Neutrality is the idea that internet service providers (ISPs), like Comcast, Verizon and AT&T, must treat all data on the internet equally, no matter who created it. The FCC made it a guiding principle of regulating ISPs in 2015. The Trump administration is now moving to reverse this decision.

Ajit Pai, Verizon, AT&T, Comcast, Time Warner, Mergers, Justice Department, FCC, Federal Communications Commission, Regulations, Net Neutrality, Repeal, Open Internet, Threat, Donald Trump, John Oliver, Reese's Cup
Would-be-harbinger-of-dystopia and most-embarassing-dad Ajit Pai is Trump’s Chairman of the FCC. A former lawyer for Verizon, Ajit is leading the charge to destroy Net Neutrality. [Image Source]
Much has been written about how these changes will shut out start-ups in entertainment and Silicon Valley by imposing enormous entry-costs. Only players with large “war chests” outside their content producing assets like Amazon, Comcast, Verizon, AT&T, Apple, etc. will be able to survive the changes. So yes. It will be bad for economic dynamism. For those who favor competitive markets as a tool to drive innovation in the arts and technology, it will be an unmitigated disaster.

What I’m more concerned about in these changes is far more insidious, and less talked about. The End of Net Neutrality is one of the worst threats to Free Speech for decades. Giving telecommunications companies the power to police content creation and distribution on the internet through pricing, access and quality-control mechanisms will also mean that we are giving them the power to police speech.

Free Speech, Threat, ISP, Net Neutrality, FCC, ACLU, Internet of Things, Open Internet, Ajit Pai, Donald Trump
‘Nuff Said. [Image Source]
In fact, they have already shown a willingness and ability to do this. The ACLU has some great examples on their website, including one from 2007:

AT&T censored words from [Pearl Jam] lead singer Eddie Vedder’s performance. The ISP, which was responsible for streaming the concert, shut off the sound as Vedder sang, “George Bush, leave this world alone” and “George Bush, find yourself another home.” By doing so, AT&T, the self-advertised presenting sponsor of the concert series, denied viewers the complete exclusive coverage they were promised. Although Vedder’s words contained no profanity, an AT&T spokesperson claimed that the words were censored to prevent youth visiting the website from being exposed to “excessive profanity.”

Remember — this was 2007, before corporations were people and themselves had free speech rights. 10 years later, in 2017, not only can companies like AT&T “speak” as much as they like through campaign contributions and unlimited political advertising, they can also, sometimes literally as above, silence opposition to their interests.

Eddie Vedder, Pearl Jam, Chicago, Concert, ACLU, Free Speech, Censorship, YouTube, George Bush, Dissent, Net Neutrality, Open Internet, FCC, Ajit Pai, Donald Trump
Now that AT&T isn’t censoring my speech because we’re all protected by Net Neutrality (at least, for now) let me sing you a song about it on a paddle board. In a suit. No socks though. Socks would be too much. [Image Source]
Also remember that the platforms through which you already receive much of your news (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.) already control what news you see and what content you consume through algorithms that encourage self-confirmation for profit. But they can only exist and thrive when internet speeds are high, and ISPs don’t target them. If the 21st century’s biggest media platforms must capitulate to ISPs interests merely to exist, imagine how easily these algorithms could be, and have been, used to warp our perceptions of reality to fall in line with ISPs interests.

It is a dystopian vision. But it’s one you can actually stop. Just like the Muslim Ban was stopped. Just like the Obamacare Repeal was stopped. These fights weren’t easy, and this one won’t be now. But you should call your representatives. Flood their inboxes. Their voice messages. Sign a petition. Protest on the street. Donate to important orgs. Find a list of things to do. Then do them. Democracy is a contact sport. Dictatorship is a spectator’s.


What have you done to prevent the end of Net Neutrality? How could you be, or have been, affected by malignant ISPs? How can Free Speech survive the digital age? Comment and share your thoughts!
Follow to get the next brooding question post right to your email, and comment below to suggest topics for future brooding.
Written and edited by Dylan Welch, co-host and creator of the Municipals podcast.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s